In my recent rewatch of Sex and the City, an episode where main character Carrie Bradshaw is forced to buy her apartment or be evicted by her ex-fiancé Aidan revealed that Carrie only has $700 in her checking account and $957 in her savings account! Indexed to inflation from 2001 to 2021, that would be approximately $1,100 in checking and $1,500 in savings. Given that Carrie’s apartment was previously rent controlled for $750 per month (a steal in New York City then and now, at around $1,200 with inflation), the bulk of her income was spent on her Achilles heel: expensive shoes—according to her, $40,000 worth!
The down payment required to buy her apartment is $30,000. After consulting a loan officer at the bank, her ex-boyfriend Big and her three closest friends, her friend Charlotte gives Carrie the engagement ring from her first marriage to float the bill and save the apartment. Carrie promises to pay Charlotte back in full.
At age 35, Carrie has little to her name in assets but “many life experiences,” she notes. As much as we like to enforce the idea of saving from a young age, Carrie makes a good point about enjoying your life while you’re young—but shoes are not the same thing as life experiences! What if Carrie had spent only half of the $40,000 that she estimated she spent on shoes, and put $20,000 in savings …
Carrie says that at this point she has lived in Manhattan for a decade, so let’s see how much money Carrie would have if she put $20,000 in her savings account for 10 years. The average savings account today has a 0.06% interest rate, meaning the money you have in your savings account will appreciate by that percentage over one year. The more you put into your savings account, the more money you’ll make in the long run. Over a 10-year period, Carrie would make about $270 on her savings, which isn’t much and wouldn’t cover her down payment.
But what if she used a high-yield savings account? High-yield savings accounts have interest rates much higher than the average bank, some as high as 0.70% today. If Carrie had her money in a high-yield savings account, she would have almost $21,000 in total savings.
This would be the best Carrie could do at this level if she still wanted to maintain half of her Manolo Blahnik shoe collection. Even with a high-yield savings account, she still wouldn’t be able to pay for her apartment on her own at today’s low interest rates.
When I first watched this episode, I was horrified by Carrie’s financial state! I couldn’t help but wonder: Would she would be able to support herself? Unfortunately, she would have to start investing or save more of her income to do anything more with her money. She might also have to sell some of those shoes, but that would be even more painful for her! Through my Carrie Finances series, I intend to teach myself about budgeting and life-planning so that my finances are in better shape by the time I turn 35 than Carrie’s are!