Setting High-Yield Savings Goals

Last time I updated you on my high-yield savings accounts, interest rates were going up and so were my savings. Since then, my LendingClub account has increased the interest rate on my savings three more times!

Back in June, LendingClub raised my rate to a 1.05% annual percentage yield (APY). By the end of June, it was 1.26%, and at the start of August it went up to 2.07%. A few days ago on September 21, it went up to 2.25%. According to LendingClub, this is 13 times the national average savings account yield. When the interest rate was 2.07% at the beginning of August, I decided to transfer more money into the account. Through the end of August (September’s interest doesn’t hit until the end of the month), I had made almost $30 on my savings since I opened the account in March 2022!

My LendingClub account is designated for a future down payment on a house, so it’s a longer-term goal that I have more funds allocated to. My other high-yield savings account with SmartyPig is for saving money before it is invested.

Though I haven’t been contacted about the interest rate going up on my SmartyPig account, it has increased from 0.75% in June to 2.05% in September. Not too shabby! When I signed up for SmartyPig, one of its offerings was the ability to set savings goals. What I didn’t realize is that the interest rate is higher when I designate funds for a specific goal—2.25% (same as my LendingClub account)!

So, I set up my first official savings goal with SmartyPig, which is to have $2,000 ready to invest by the start of 2023. When I began investing in March 2022, that was my Schwab account’s starting balance. At that point, it was all I was willing to part with; I knew I should only be investing money I was comfortable losing. Since then, my threshold for losing money has increased (since the market has been down for most of this year). However, I also know that I’m in my investments for the long term, so the short-term ups and downs aren’t crucial to my end goal. Maybe 2023 will be a better year if people stop saying the world “recession”—don’t let the market hear you!

I’ll keep you updated on how this savings goal goes and when I solidify a better plan for transferring my savings to all of their different homes on a more regular basis. Half the battle is just figuring out what works for me and my money, the rest should be relatively easy (fingers crossed!).

High-Yield Savings Accounts: Where Are They Now?

While I may not be making money in my investments right now, my high-yield savings accounts are making me more than I’ve made in years on my savings!

The market is down. Even if you’re not in the market, I’m sure you heard. But I’ve been trained well by AAII; I’m not scared by the red numbers on my Schwab account. In fact, I’ve made friends with them! We’re getting brunch on Sunday since the market is closed.

You might also be hearing about interest rates lately, and the possibility of them being raised. One of my savings accounts just raised my interest rate! It was an email I actually wanted to see from an institution I keep my money with. My high-yield savings account with LendingClub is now yielding 1.05% per year, up from 0.65% when I opened my account. LendingClub also noted that there is no minimum balance for my account (before it was $2,500). This makes me excited to see what this account can do for me; it’s already made a whopping $6.44 since the end of March (compared to $0.13 a month on my regular savings account, we’re living like kings).

I recall Erin Lowry saying 1.05% is the best rate on the market in “Broke Millennial,” so I feel like I lucked out with LendingClub. But Lowry also says, “Online banks will routinely fiddle around with the APY on savings accounts. One month it’s 1.05 percent APY, and two months later it drops to 0.75 percent. It’s actually within the bank’s right to do this—but that doesn’t mean you should hang tight at your measly 0.01 percent rate with your current bank because another bank might change from 1.00 percent APY to something a little bit lower. Because 0.75 percent still crushes 0.01 percent.” It’s good to know that my interest rate might not stay at 1.05% forever, especially since interest rates are fluctuating in other areas of the economy.

So with this higher interest rate, I should probably add more money to my LendingClub savings account to take advantage of it! My other high-yield savings account with SmartyPig is also doing well, and I’ll be adding more money to it soon to make the most of the 0.75% yield.

If you want to know more about interest rates, AAII’s financial writers and guest writers all have much smarter things to say than I do—I’m still recovering from high school trigonometry.

Opening High-Yield Savings Accounts

Last time I wrote about savings accounts, I asked my Instagram followers if they knew the interest rate on their savings accounts. I gave them four options: 1) Yes, but it sucks; 2) Yes, it’s actually making me money!; 3) No; and 4) I don’t have a savings account.

I got 15 responses: Three of my friends said they know their interest rate, but it sucks; six said they don’t know the interest rate; and six don’t have a savings account. I would say most of my followers fall between the ages of 20 and 40, and some of those without savings accounts are either younger than me or not working full-time yet.

However, no one selected, “Yes, it’s actually making me money!” This didn’t surprise me, but it motivated me to continue my research and finally open some high-yield savings accounts.

First, I revisited SmartyPig, which still offers a 0.70% annual percentage yield (APY), or interest rate, on my savings. This account will let me save up to $10,000 at this high interest rate, but once I have more than that the APY drops to 0.45%. I decided to call this my “grower not shower” savings account, where I’ll put money before investing it so that I can make the most of it before its intended purpose.

Signing up for a SmartyPig account was easy, it just required my name, address, Social Security number and creating some security questions. At some point I was asked if I had lived at my current address for more than two years. When I said no, I was asked to also enter my previous address. Once I read the disclaimers, I was able to manually connect my current bank savings account to make a transfer.

Then I wanted to look at some high-yield options that gave me more flexibility with my savings. LendingClub now offers a 0.65% APY, higher than it was when I last looked into it! The only restriction is that I must have at least $2,500 in the account. I’m calling this one my “movin’ on up” savings account where I’ll be putting funds to save up for buying a place in the future!

Opening an account with LendingClub was slightly different than SmartyPig. I was asked to create a security phrase, and I was able to connect my bank automatically using Plaid. From there, I could designate which account I wanted to connect and choose the amount I wanted to transfer. There were many disclosures to read, but most didn’t apply to the high-yield savings account I was opening and were instead about LendingClub’s other banking and card offers.

I decided to open two different high-yield savings accounts so that I can maximize the yields across both, and because I want to keep my savings goals separate as Bola Sokunbi explained in “Clever Girl Finance.” For now I’m keeping my regular savings account with my bank, designating it for emergency savings.

I’ll keep you updated on how my plan goes, and as it changes along the way!

What Is the Purpose of a Savings Account?

In previous blog posts I described myself as a big saver, but I wasn’t much of one before I got my savings account. I opened my savings account back in 2016 after I graduated from college. I was working consistently and paying off my student loans, but my parents encouraged me to put money into my savings account because if I kept it in my checking account I was just going to spend it!

Savings accounts are basically your bank paying you to keep your money with it. I think of my savings account as a place to hold money before its intended use. The average savings account today has a 0.06% interest rate, meaning the money in your savings account will appreciate by that percentage over one year. It’s definitely not a place for my money to grow—I’m making $0.14 per month at most on my savings. Rather, it’s a place to accumulate money until it’s time for it to shine and fulfill one of my goals.

I learned from Bola Sokunbi in her book “Clever Girl Finance” that psychologically it’s better to separate savings for different goals into their own savings accounts to not only avoid confusion but to not feel that you’re being set back on your other goals when you need something for one specific goal. Right now I have money to be invested and my emergency savings in the same account, but they should really be in separate places so I can see my goals clearer. Thankfully they soon will be, but I also want to look into a high-yield savings account, which I learned about while dissecting Carrie Bradshaw’s financial situation.

First, it’s important to make sure that any bank you’re putting your money in is insured by the Federal Deposit Insurance Corp. (FDIC). This means that your money will be safe should the bank go under. You can check if a bank is FDIC insured here.

After some researching and reading reviews, I found a few candidates for my future high-yield savings account: Sallie Mae’s SmartyPig, Axos Bank, LendingClub and Discover. SmartyPig offers a 0.70% annual percentage yield (APY) or interest rate on my savings, but the caveat for this higher yield is that it only applies to amounts under $10,000. Once you have more than $10,000 in your SmartyPig account, the APY falls to 0.45%. Axos Bank can give you 0.61% per year up to $24,999, but after you hit $25,000 the APY is much lower at 0.25% and goes down to 0.15% on more than $100,000. LendingClub offers 0.60% APY for balances of $2,500 or more. Through AAII’s partnership with Discover, you can get 0.55% APY without any restrictions or minimums (this is higher than what you can get through Discover without being an AAII member). These are all high yields with good options—I would just have to decide which option fits each goal. Maybe I’ll end up having more than one high-yield savings account to maximize the interest rates for the amount of money I want to save.

On the topic of how much you should have in a savings account, I recall many years ago when someone told me that they couldn’t believe a person they knew had more than $100,000 in their savings account. I knew that having too much in a savings account was as bad as not having enough—the opportunity cost of not growing all of that money in investments outweighed having all of that money stowed away, and in a manner akin to stuffing cash under your mattress!

I will be revisiting this high-yield savings account research when I open one in the near future, so stick around for more of my investing discoveries!